Square pies named for streets in the neighborhood nourish & amuse at this NoLita pizzeria.
When a place says they’re “delivering happiness one slice at a time,” you hope it’s true and this spot absolutely lives up to it. We ordered a slice of the Naughty Pie (spicy vodka sauce, pepperoni, ricotta, and hot honey), and let me just say… I went to heaven and came right back down just to grab another slice. The balance of spicy, creamy, and sweet was unreal. Every bite was fresh, flavorful, and perfectly crisp. It’s the kind of pizza that makes you pause mid-bite because it’s that good. This is definitely more of a grab-your-slice-and-go kind of place. They do have a few high-top tables, but it gets crowded quickly because it’s so popular. That said, the line moves fast, so don’t let it scare you away. Safe to say, this is officially on my must-go list. I’ll absolutely be checking out their San Diego location and any others I can find because I already know I’ll be dreaming about this pizza. 🍕
Pizza was slamming good with plenty of pepperoni and burned the top of my mouth. As it should. Well Worth the trip. What I really liked, as the original site of Ray’s pizza, the prices aren’t gougy and the staff totally unpretentious. This is a real pizza joint delivering delicious slices for their neighbors.
Tried the naughty pie slice and it was amazing!! The flavor and the crunch were perfect! Definitely different than a regular pepperoni pizza. Would highly recommend and would definitely come back. No inside seating available. There are a few standing tables outside the store but they may or may not be available immediately. Definitely try it fresh.
The pepperoni square pizza was as delicious as it looks, the service was ok but the gentleman that spoke to me was hard to understand. No bathrooms here for customers and you will most likely stand if you're eating inside which is a very small crowded area. I love those white & green checkered pizza boxes and the vibe in and around the Prince Street area. I would definitely go back! With a bathroom and a place to sit I would have gave 5 stars!
Every trending spot in NYC, in your inbox each morning.